McAfee has been highly critical of this team throughout the season, notably after quarterback Anthony Richardson pulled himself out of a Week 8 game for being tired before a third down play in the red zone. The ESPN star called for Richardson’s job immediately and later questioned the leadership on the team after they lost to the Giants in Week 17.

Former Indianapolis Colts punter Pat McAfee didn't mince his words on what the team should do with Jonathan Taylor.

McAfee dove into the topic on his Thursday show, lamenting the fact that the Colts cannot simply wave a wand and get a do-over. “I wish we could transfer portal the whole f–-ing team,” McAfee said. “We need like 70 guys to hit the portal,